Home / Opinion / Letters to the Editor / Gutierrez sent a message, but what was it?

Gutierrez sent a message, but what was it?

Upon causing himself to be arrested during his protest of SB1070, former Arizona Sen. Alfredo Gutierrez stated: “We were sending a message to the Hispanic community.”

But what is the “message?” And what is the “Hispanic community?” Is it anyone with a Spanish heritage — does that include only first-generation Mexicans or also second-generation or third-generation? Is it only people born in Mexico, or those also born in Central America? Does it include people born in Spain? Is it everyone who speaks Spanish?

Or does Gutierrez mean to speak only of people born in Mexico who are also in the U.S. illegally? Or could he mean a much larger group such as people who self identify with Mexican culture, who like Mariachi music, or who like Mexican food?

Maybe there is really no such thing as a “Hispanic community” that can be identified in any way other than ways that are purely political and that directly reflect political viewpoints. This, of course, means that Gutierrez is just playing politics, not, as he might like us to believe, pursuing some loftier cause.

And what is the “message” that Gutierrez is sending? Apparently the group he represents wants something — that is, they want to stop action by the government they disapprove of, or they want to force some action by the government that they approve of and are willing to use the color of their skin as a weapon to get it.

The use of language like the language employed by Gutierrez is simply racism — that is, a blatant attempt to use race as a divisive weapon to get something instead of sticking with arguing the issues on their merits. That makes him part of the problem, not part of the solution.

— Roy Miller, Phoenix


  1. Wow, Roy, that is such a clever way to hide the racist nature of your comments: declare the antagonist a racist. But you think that anyone protesting against new “Jim Crow” laws is a racist? Wow, Wow, Wow… Just another bunch of right-wing double-speak that tells us that black is white and up is down. Only pathetically stupid people would fall for this drivel!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

The coal-fired Navajo Generating Station in northeast Arizona provides almost 1,000 jobs between the plant and the mine that supplies it, but the plant's operators have said they plan to shut it down after 2019. (Photo by Amber Brown/Courtesy SRP)

Closing the Navajo Generating Station comes with disastrous consequences (access required)

Citing the costs of complying with federal environmental regulations and responding to the declining prices of natural gas, the Navajo Generating Station's owners voted earlier this year to take the facility offline about 25 years ahead of schedule. Those same factors have driven the closures of many coal-fired electricity generating plants nationwide.