Home / Capitol Insiders / Democrats: Klein’s letter-reading offensive, ignorant

Democrats: Klein’s letter-reading offensive, ignorant

Rep. Catherine Miranda, D-Phoenix, speaks alongside other members of the Latino Democrat caucus (Photo by Evan Wyloge/Arizona Capitol Times)

Rep. Catherine Miranda, D-Phoenix, speaks alongside other Latino lawmakers about a letter Sen. Lori Klein read from the Senate floor this past week, during debates over several immigration bills. (Photo by Evan Wyloge/Arizona Capitol Times)

Latino Democrats today said a Republican senator made an “offensive and ignorant” decision when she read a racially tinged letter on the Senate floor during the debate of an immigration bill last week.

The Democrats said Sen. Lori Klein, R-Anthem, needs to apologize to the public. They also said she can’t back off from responsibility by claiming she just read a letter.

By reading a letter from a substitute teacher who said he had found that Hispanic students “would rather be gang members and gangsters” than receive an education, they said Klein deliberately injected race into the issue of illegal immigration, even though advocates of a strict-enforcement approach to confronting the emotional and complex problem consistently deny the issue is related to race.

“The words spoken by Senator Klein last week on the Senate floor (go) beyond recklessness and ignorance,” said Rep. Catherine Miranda, D-Phoenix. “Her willingness to associate herself with an anonymous letter that contains explicit racial connotations clearly reflects her views of Latinos, or her lack of maturity, and ignorance.”

During the March 17 debate, Klein read a letter that painted a disparaging picture of Hispanic students. The substitute teacher also wrote that the Hispanic students “hate America and are determined to reclaim this area for Mexico.”

“For someone to say that all Hispanics want to do is grow up to be gangbangers and return this country to Mexico — I find truly offensive,” said Rep. Ruben Gallego, D-Phoenix.

But Klein said she merely presented another side to an issue. Senate President Russell Pearce, who actually forwarded the letter to Klein, said he is shocked that Democrats have been quick to “defend the actions of these troublemakers, and mock the frustration many teachers feel in bringing order to the classroom.”

Pearce said he has spoken with the teacher who wrote him the letter and he stood by his description of his classroom experience.

“Some members of the minority are now calling for me to apologize, and calling for Sen. Klein to apologize for reading it. We will not apologize,” Pearce said in a written statement. “A teacher has a First Amendment right to express themselves, and we have an obligation to our citizens to keep them informed on what is happening in our schools.”

Yesterday, Klein agreed that the letter needs to be verified and admitted she read it without confirming if the experience was factual.

“I think basically we need to make sure it is verified. I just assumed because of, you know, where I received it that it was already verified,” she said.

The letter was actually addressed to Pearce, who forwarded it to other Republicans.

When asked if she was surprised by the reaction, Klein said: “What’s wrong with presenting another side to an issue that’s really important?”

In an interview, Pearce said people can read the letter themselves and decide how to view it.

“The truth apparently offends some people and some people can’t handle the truth,” Pearce said.


  1. Pearce is EVERYTHING that is wrong for Arizona. I don’t know how a white supremacist become a leader in the Senate. Little Rusty doesn’t know what the hell he’s talking about. He conjures up bills that are unconstitutional and wastes valuable time that should be used to solve Arizona problems, like job, jobs, jobs. He seems to want to push Arizona into that “mecca of prejudice and bigotry.” Look in the dictionary for BIGOT and you will fine Rusty Pearce. I taught for over 3 decades in the Phoenix area and I had a variety of ethnic groups as students. I find the Hispanics were much more respectful and they valued education more than many of my non-Hispanic students. In fact, I can’t remember a Hispanic or Asian or Iraqi or Iranian ever giving me trouble.
    Klein is an idiot. That letter represented ONE bigoted person’s opinion of Hispanics from his vast sometimes-a-teacher experience, not one side of the argument. If I knew a substitute like this, he would never step one foot inside my classroom. This letter she chose to read is just as damaging because it is what she thinks. I’m tired of being embarrassed for Arizona.

  2. I am embarrassed that these elected officials are supposed to represent Arizona. Klein comes across as the racist bigot she truly is! No Klein, not all Hispanics want to grow up to be gang members, and not all “white” kids want to grow up to be skin heads. As a Hispanic female who currently holds two graduate degrees I listen to the garbage that spews from your and Little Rusty’s mouth and can only feel sorry for you and your narrow minded ignorance.

  3. This says it all:

    “Yesterday, Klein agreed that the letter needs to be verified and admitted she read it without confirming if the experience was factual.”

    just because you read something on the Senate floor, does not make it “”presenting another side to an issue that’s really important”…

    There are a million points of view, but you dont read the most outrageous and pretend it represents the mainstream…

  4. Arizona’s Border Defense Prayer

    Obama like Nero sings, midst Arizona’s border flames and travail,
    hoodwinked Justice drops her scales, and totters from her sacred dais.
    Virtue and freedom are thy care here below Arizona,
    be not the parricide of those who gave thee being.
    Arizonan’s ne’er bowed their knee to idolish power,
    and still lisp freedom ‘pon freedmen’s lips,
    though every tie of Law and Justice now be broken.
    Arizona, indignant Justice begs of thee protection,
    from Constitution’s now mangled law and reason.
    Arizona, defend thy daughters, defend thy sons,
    defend them all, yes every one,
    From border anarchy which comes to slay them.

  5. DixieSuzanne – That was some weird sh-t you wrote!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

(Photo by Luige del Puerto/Arizona Capitol Times)

For the DeMennas, the business of government is a family affair (access required)

It’s common for children to follow in the footsteps of their parents, but in politics, that’s usually the case for elected officials, not lobbyists, and that’s one reason why the DeMennas occupy an unusual perch.