Home / Opinion / Commentary / Ducey budget will protect Arizona’s taxpayers, producers and consumers

Ducey budget will protect Arizona’s taxpayers, producers and consumers

campaign finance money flag capitolThe Arizona Legislature has always had a solid core of real fiscal conservatives who believe in balanced budgets and want to protect Arizona’s taxpayers, producers and consumers. But for the first time in recent memory, an Arizona governor is actually taking the leadership role of holding the line against the growth of Big Government.

To protect Arizona’s taxpayers, producers and consumers, the Arizona chapter of Americans for Prosperity is urging legislators and their constituents to support the overall direction of the executive budget released on Jan. 16 by Governor Doug Ducey.

First and foremost, AFP-Arizona strongly agrees with Governor Ducey that Arizona needs to put more money in our classrooms, and to stop wasting taxpayer dollars on excess administration, frivolous capital and soft capital projects, and services that do not directly improve front-line classroom instruction.

According to the latest available annual report from the state superintendent of public instruction, total annual funding in Arizona from all sources (local, state, and federal) was over $8,000 per pupil. That is a LOT of money. With an average classroom of 25 students, that means there is $200,000 of potential resources in that classroom. Think about that for a moment.

If a school district limited capital maintenance, administrative overhead and other services to one-third of expenditures ($66,000), it could allocate $66,000 for the salary and benefits of a good teacher in every classroom, and still allocate another $66,000 to pay a special education instructor to work with the IEPs in every classroom.

(Go ahead: Ask your favorite front-line teachers if they actually make $66,000 a year. Perhaps some senior teachers make that much, but you’ll probably find that the only folks making that much money are administrators, many of whom rake in six figures.)

With Ducey, we also believe that the corporate special interests in Arizona can do without the $100 million slush fund Ducey proposes to take away from the Arizona Commerce Authority. And we believe that the educrats at our community colleges who waste taxpayer money and student tuition dollars can do without the $84 million Ducey proposes as reductions to higher education budgets.

The executive budgets of Governors Napolitano and Brewer had absurdly high revenue projections and dangerously high spending proposals that had to be cut down by the real leaders in the Legislature. But it’s a new day in Arizona.

By making more than $660 million in spending reductions to the FY 2016 budget, and by making $450 million in permanent spending reductions in FY 2017, Governor Ducey’s proposal has the potential to give Arizona a structurally balanced state budget for the first time since the go-go days of the real estate boom, seven years ago.

Bonus: Ducey’s plan has the potential to balance the budget without reneging on previously-enacted pro-growth tax cuts. (We’re not in favor of raising the vehicle registration fee, but if you’re looking for small amounts of revenue, it’s better to go with a genuine user fee, rather than raising general revenue taxes.)

More broadly, Ducey’s budget proposal has the potential to get Arizona off the spending rollercoaster that crashed state finances in the past decade. Ducey’s $9.1 billion budget is well under the prudent budget growth limit of population-plus-inflation.

Of course, this will not be an easy fight. Arizona’s legislators are constantly surrounded by the wailing and moaning of the Big Government spending lobbies. The school district bureaucrats, corporate crony capitalists, and educrats at our community colleges and universities – and their hundreds of paid lobbyists – are going to fight hard to try to water down Governor Ducey’s budget reductions.

AFP-Arizona encourages all of Arizona’s taxpayers, families and businesses to TAKE ACTION TODAY and contact their legislators in support of Governor Ducey’s budget reforms.

– Tom Jenney is Arizona director of Americans for Prosperity  (www.aztaxpayers.org).


  1. I would only note that the $8000 spent per student in Arizona ranks its spending among the lowest five states in the United States, according to the US Census. Also, the estimates about how schools spend that money are ill-informed an unrealistic, especially when the average teach in Arizona earns a salary of just below $50,000 (not including benefits.)

    If the state doesn’t fund education, either at the K-12 or University level, it will hurt the ability of business to succeed and we’ll see further steady erosion of our economy.

    Consider, the case of higher education and prisons. Gov. Ducey proposes a budget of $1B to house 42,000+ inmates in correctional facilities, but about $720M for the state’s three universities, serving more than 130,000 students.

    Business and economies do not thrive in places that emphasize prison over education, or where local and state governments invest poorly–(i.e. prison over education.) Its not “reform” to fund the private prison industry and its high-paid lobbyists.

    Families and communities should tell Gov. Ducey to get his spending priorities straight, to fund those services that benefit the state’s businesses and its residents.

  2. Mr. Jenney,

    Give me proof that all the tax cuts and credits enacted over the past 20 years have brought such great prosperity to the state. Give me facts that show where each of these credits/taxes lead to higher economic growth and higher wages. The Legislature has never produced a study to show any tangible benefit from these tax cuts and credits — just words that say its so. I know that because I’ve asked the Joint Legislative Budget Committee if any studies have been produced and was told there were none.

    What drove the state’s growth until the recession was population growth, mainly due to in-migration. Population growth has dried up and that’s why the state hasn’t been able to produce the revenue needed to provide services for education, child protection and government oversight. Arizona was able to get by by significantly cutting income, corporate and property taxes over the last two decades because sales taxes grew with population growth. Take away the sales tax growth and keep cutting taxes and you will get growing deficits. I wrote about this two months ago in an opinion article published here, back up with facts, not rhetoric.

    Gov. Ducey and the Legislature will lead us down a path of more deficits if they get their wish to eliminate income (personal and corporate) taxes. These individuals proposing to do this are not fiscal conservatives, but fiscally irresponsible. Companies don’t just move to the state because you lower their taxes. They are concerned about infrastructure, schools, and quality of life. The income disparity in this state is growing larger and larger because of all the low-wage jobs being created by this race to the bottom.

    I’m sorry that there are so many people and special interests in this state who don’t want to pay their fair share of taxes and spend millions to elect legislators and a governor who will do their bidding. That doesn’t mean there aren’t savings that can’t be found in education and in government. There are, but they must be balanced against the need to appropriately fund the drivers of a higher standing of living — education, health care and good government.

    Brent Fine

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

Medical Concept: Black Chalkboard with Abortion. Medical Concept - Abortion Handwritten on Black Chalkboard. Top View Composition with Chalkboard and Red Stethoscope. 3D Rendering.

Bill would help meet needs of women who don’t want abortion

When I volunteered with a pregnancy resource center, many of the women I met didn’t want to choose abortion but felt they didn’t have a choice due to lack of resources or support.

/* code for tag simpli.fi */