Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Home / Opinion / Commentary / Despite benefits of tax cuts, critics continue to attack

Despite benefits of tax cuts, critics continue to attack


A new report from Fidelity Investments is yet another reminder of the white-hot American economy induced by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. According to data from the second quarter of 2018, there are now more retirement accounts worth over $1 million than ever before — roughly 50,000 more than just last year.

That means more everyday Americans are able to retire comfortably without financial worry.

More evidence of success from the tax relief package are obvious and plentiful. Small business optimism is at a record high. Unemployment is historically low. Over 700 companies, including some of the nation’s largest employers, have reinvested their tax cut savings into worker compensation. And the most recent GDP growth figures reported that the economy is growing at a rate of 4.1 percent — quicker than most thought possible just a few years ago.

Drew John

Drew John

Meanwhile, over 90 percent of middle-class families are getting a tax cut, according to the left-of-center Tax Policy Center. The average family can expect roughly $2,000 in savings every year.

Yet, critics of the tax bill continue to pull dishonest attacks out of the woodwork.

First they tried to belittle the tax savings as crumbs. And when that didn’t work — unsurprisingly so since essentially everyone is benefiting in one way or another — they tried to spin the new standard deduction and lower rates for small businesses as a windfall for the wealthy. But anyone with eyes can see that the owner of the pizza shop on the corner or the general store down the street aren’t affluent millionaires.

Opponents of the tax cuts are throwing all the attacks they can conjure against the wall. But since the facts aren’t on their side, nothing will stick.

Unfortunately, they’re so committed to these tried-and-failed policies that they’ve stuck their heads in the sand to avoid all the good news about the federal tax cuts.

In a recent batch of headlines, the power of the tax cuts is unleashing American industry. Over 95 percent of manufacturers, large and small, feel good about their economic prospects — the highest level since the National Association of Manufacturers started measuring outlooks 20 years ago. Manufacturers are also raising wages, hiring new workers, expanding benefits, and purchasing new equipment.

CEOs say the tax cuts are spurring them to increase hiring and spending. Small businesses are also doing well. More small businesses plan to grow wages and operations than have in decades. Overall wages are growing faster and average base wages are up. Unemployment is low for everyone, but especially for minority groups compared to historical data.

Voters know the tax cuts work. Majorities have long supported the new code, approved of the economy, and expressed satisfaction with their opportunity to get ahead today. And consumer confidence remains strong.

All the griping from the critics hasn’t made a dent.

As the data rolls in, it’s clear that the tax cuts have produced such remarkable results while ensuring that the burdens of our tax code are well-balanced and fairly distributed. Nonpartisan experts estimate that high earners will pay more of the tax code burden this year than last and Americans in lower brackets will pay less.

Politics always gets heated in an election year. And Democrats and their well-funded activist army want to make tax cuts the wedge issue. That’s fine. While they try to ride their shopworn talking points to victory, Arizona voters will respond with something real that’s on the line: their bigger paychecks.

Drew John, a Republican from Safford, represents Legislative District 14 in the Arizona House of Representatives.


The views expressed in guest commentaries are those of the author and are not the views of the Arizona Capitol Times.


  1. bradley taylor hudson

    This article is misleading. Not knowing Mr. John, I can’t say whether he is malicious or simply white. Does Mr. John really describe those with retirement accounts of over $1 million as “everyday Americans”? If he is not joking, he is showing how out of touch the rich are. I could not find any statements from the Tax Policy Center to support the numbers Mr. John uses, but I can say that the TPC opinions do not support Mr. John’s position. The predictions that economic gains for the average American are small and temporary, while gains for the rich are large and long term, still stand. …. It is true that we needed a stimulus, but this is not the one we needed. We did not need to give the rich so much money. The Average American will eventually be paying that debt. We needed that money to further stimulate. ….. Mr. Johns claims that voters support the tax cuts is also misleading. Anyone can read to see that virtually every poll shows the opposite. ….. Mr. Johns then goes on to discuss investments due to tax cuts, ignoring the very small percentage of the tax cut money that was reinvested. By far, most was turned into simple profit for the rich. ….. There is just too much information readily available for anyone to believe this article.

  2. How long will the tax-cut infused bump last and what will be the repercussions then?

  3. At what point will Arizona realize that they are not fully and properly funding schools and other key infrastructure items in order to give a few companies a few million dollars. They sacrifice the common good in order to fellate a few rich donors. No one (outside of shareholders and CEO’s) see any benefit from these tax cuts but they cause the rest of the state and society to suffer from the want of what these taxes do. And for those of you who babble “tax cuts pay for themselves” then why is the Arizona School budget 820 Million Dollars LESS that it was 10 years ago. When will these tax cuts make up for that shortfall?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

Protect prescription drug affordability for AZ families

As working families and businesses across Arizona already struggle with record inflation and the ongoing economic recovery, it is more important than ever that lawmakers protect patients from higher drug costs.

/* code for tag */