Month: August 2008
No hand-count; Majority Rules initiative certified for ballot
A highly controversial initiative that seeks to put the brakes on Arizona’s ballot initiative process was certified to appear on the 2008 ballot by Secretary of State Jan Brewer on Aug. 25.
Prop. 105, the Majority Rules initiative, seeks to require future ballot initiatives that raise taxes or obligate state spending be approved by at least a majority of registered voters for the proposals to become law, not merely a majority of those who actually vote.
Proponents of the initiative, which Brewer found to have at least 98 percent of the minimum amount of signatures needed to qualify, argue it is necessary to make it more difficult for well-financed special interest groups to push their costly agendas by putting measures to a public vote.
Contributors to the Majority Rules campaign include the fast food and liquor industries and Tucson auto dealer Jim Click. According to a recent campaign finance report, the campaign committee has raised approximately $565,000.
Political consultant Nathan Sproul said the committee was “ecstatic” at the qualification of the proposal, which he thinks of as the first serious attempt to address the state’s “near-crisis” budget shortfall – a condition he partially attributed to government spending mandated by successful ballot initiatives.
“Something has to be done to curtail the ability of special interests to use the initiative process as their own personal ATM machines,” Sproul said.
A ballot initiative committee headed by the Arizona Education Association, the state’s largest teachers’ union, has formed to oppose the measure. The committee has collected about $95,000 from educational associations and a firefighters’ union.
John Wright, AEA president and chairman of the No on Prop. 105 committee, wrote in the secretary of state’s publicity pamphlet that the measure is a “deceptive” effort that makes it “nearly impossible” for citizens to use the ballot to make impacts on public policy.
The measure is also being opposed by a host of environmental groups, proponents of publicly funded political campaigns, former lawmakers, current candidates, women’s organizations and animal rights advocates.
Brewer’s announcement of the qualifying of the Majority Rules initiative came with a detectable dose of resentment that measures are being approved for the ballot even though it is not clear they have the minimum amount of needed signatures to qualify.
Typically, initiatives that are estimated to have between 95 and 105 percent of the required number of valid signatures to appear on the ballot trigger an automatic hand-count by counties to ensure they are fit to qualify.
But this year is different, as several counties have notified the Secretary of State’s Office that they do not have the means to conduct time-consuming hand-counts.
And a result of a decades-old court decision, several initiatives this year have been granted access to the ballot, even though it is not clear they had the minimum amount of signatures.
In 1983, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled that the benefit of the doubt must be given to the ballot initiative committees when it ordered the Save Our Public Lands Coalition initiative to appear on the ballot.
Brewer said the approval of the Majority Rules initiative came as a result of advice from her attorneys, and she called for the state Legislature or the courts to enact clarifications explaining why measures that do not clearly qualify should go to voters.
“Hopefully, the Legislature or the courts will help clarify in the future how it is that 98 percent really means 100 percent when it comes to the signature requirements of a citizen initiative,” she said.
Youngest AZ delegate praises Gov. Schweitzer
At 19-years-old, Adam Lopez Falk was the youngest Arizona delegate at the Democratic National Convention. And he took the responsibility very seriously — he said his favorite extracurricular activity was attending the Hispanic Caucus meetings.
He came to Denver to support Hillary Clinton, but he’s also behind Barack Obama now that he’s the nominee.
And he really likes Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer, who dressed down for his speech and really got the crowd going.
What do you think so far of the events? What is your impression?
I’ve had a lot of fun so far. The speeches have been great. Michelle Obama the first night and Hillary the second night. But the one I really enjoyed was Brian Schweitzer of Montana. He was the most energetic. I thought he should have been the keynote speaker. He’s just a real personable guy.
How did you become a delegate?
A friend of mine is a district-wide delegate and he told me I should become an at-large delegate. I had worked for Clinton’s campaign and volunteered for Congressman Ed Pastor. So, I was excited about the campaign and decided to apply.
What did you think about the speech by Hillary Clinton?
I think it was great. I was impressed by it. I hope she silenced a lot of her critics. She seemed really honest and she said she is going to vote for Obama and support him. I’m still a little upset that she’s not the nominee, but you can’t win every time. And now I’m here to support Obama.
Have you noticed a split among delegates supporting Obama and Clinton?
I support Clinton and she’s the reason I’m here. When it’s all said and done, I’ll vote for Obama and support him. But until we have to, I’m sticking with Hillary.
The first night’s speeches were very personal. The speakers went on the attack after that. Which method is more effective?
The first night was just kind of getting to know Michelle Obama for ourselves. I like her but she didn’t seem as independent as Hillary was when Bill Clinton was president. We were just energized by all the speakers, especially Schweitzer — he was awesome. He was up there in his jeans and cowboy boots and bola tie — he represented the West very well.
What did you think of Napolitano’s speech on Aug. 26? She really went after McCain and said she hopes the tradition of Arizona presidential candidates losing the election will continue this year.
I think it was good. It’s a shame Mo Udall didn’t get in, but he took it in stride. And I hope McCain will do the same when he loses. I really enjoyed how Napolitano gave a shout out to Arizona, and it’s good to see someone from McCain’s home state go after him like that.
What has been your favorite extracurricular activity here, besides the main event speeches?
Going to the caucus meetings. I’ve been attending the Hispanic caucuses — that’s been my favorite event. The receptions and parties are a good chance to meet people. I’ve met a lot of my heroes. I met George McGovern yesterday. It’s just awesome.
For a preview of the Republican National Convention and complete coverage of the Democratic National Convention, visit http://elections.azcapitoltimes.com/.
Alternate Clinton delegate speaks out for Obama
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Transit, trust land proposals expire
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Taxation without representation is back
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Stop the press! Judge blocks ballot printing
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Brewer concedes gay marriage measure description to Goddard
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Payday-loan ballot language good to go, judge says
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Arizona delegation helps Obama become first black nominee
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Napolitano, Dems step up attack on McCain
DENVER — Forget the niceties of the first night.
The speeches on the Pepsi Center floor were acerbic on the second and third days of the Democratic National Convention. Democrats relentlessly criticized Arizona Sen. John McCain, and linked him over and over to President Bush.
The most common phrases coming from the podium were “we cannot afford more of the same” and “four more months.”
Gov. Janet Napolitano went hard after McCain.
She told the thousands gathered inside the Pepsi Center that she wants one “tradition” in her home state to continue: the trend of Arizona politicians losing in presidential elections.
“There’s a pattern here. Barry Goldwater ran for president and he lost. Mo Udall ran for president. He lost. Bruce Babbitt ran for president. And he lost,” Napolitano told the crowd. “Speaking for myself, and for at least this coming election, this is one Arizona tradition I’d like to see continue.”
And she was just warming up. Napolitano said she wanted to say “something positive” about McCain, and it went like this:
“When I heard him say the economy is not an issue he understands as well as he should, my problem was solved,” Napolitano said. “Because I can say to you tonight, positively, that John McCain is right. He doesn’t understand the economy as well as he should. And he doesn’t understand how the policies he has supported and wants to perpetuate have so terribly misfired.”
Other speakers talked about McCain’s voting record and his stand on issues — on energy, health care, etc. — to emphasize how they have been a part of Bush’s “failed policies” and to highlight their difference from Obama’s.
The speeches were a departure from the opening night of the convention, when the Democrats highlighted Ted Kennedy’s life and listened to Michelle Obama talk about her family, striking a positive note and refraining from going after McCain.
There was a pattern in the speeches. It was about the Obama family on the first night. The second night focused on more immediate concerns at home — the economy, health care, solar energy. The third night sought to portray Obama as the man who would make the right foreign policy and national security decisions.
Except on the first day, the speeches portrayed McCain as wedded to the past and too closely tied to Bush.
Napolitano said her work as chairwoman of the party’s platform drafting committee provided an opportunity to listen to Americans tell her how badly “Bush-McCain’s” economic policies have failed.
She listed what Obama would do: provide a tax rebate for middle-income taxpayers while exempting lower-income seniors from paying income tax; give $4,000 in tax credits to students who promise to give back through community service; invest in a clean energy economy and diminish America’s reliance on foreign oil.
Former Virginia Gov. Mark Warner laid out the argument for an Obama presidency by framing the race for the White House as a choice between the future and the past.
“The race for the future is on,” Warner said in his keynote speech before thousands of delegates inside the Pepsi Center in Denver on Aug. 26.
“It won’t be won with yesterday’s ideas and yesterday’s divisions. And it won’t be won with a president who is stuck in the past,” he said. “We need a president who understands the world today, the future we seek and the change we need.”
Like the speakers before him, Warner sought to tie McCain to Bush, a harbinger of how the Democrats and Obama’s camp will run their campaign in the months running up to November.
“John McCain,” Warner said, “promises more of the same — a plan that would explode the deficit that will be passed on to our kids. No real strategy to invest in our crumbling infrastructure. And he would continue spending $10 billion a month in Iraq.”
Warner said everyone in America should get a fair shot at success.
“Barack Obama understands this, because he’s lived it,” he said. “And Barack Obama is running to restore that fair shot for every American.”
On Aug. 27, the third night of their convention, Democrats lined up speakers to vouch for Barack Obama’s ability to make the right national security and foreign policy decisions.
“No president can be expected to solve every problem, but Senator Obama has already shown that he has the toughness and good judgment needed to confront our enemies without alienating friends,” said Madeleine Albright, who served as U.S. secretary of state under President Clinton.
Former presidential candidate John Kerry said Bush, with McCain “at his side, promised to spread freedom but delivered the wrong war in the wrong place at the wrong time.”
Joe Biden, the vice presidential nominee, said McCain is his friend.
“But I profoundly disagree with the direction that John wants to take the country,” he said in his prepared statement.
He added: “And when he says he will continue to spend $10 billion a month in Iraq when Iraq is sitting on a surplus of nearly $80 billion, that’s not change; that’s more of the same.”
The final night of the convention broke from the ordinary, as an estimated 75,000 people packed into Invesco Field at Mile High to hear Obama’s acceptance speech.
It was the first time in recent history that a convention’s main event was open to the public, Democrats said. And the outreach to regular Americans didn’t end there; Obama’s campaign continued to use modern technology such as text messaging to try new things to engage voters.
Throughout the final evening, leading up to Obama’s speech, people from across the United States streamed text messages in support of Obama across the big screens at Invesco.
“I support Obama because he will follow through on his promises as president,” according to one of the messages on the screen sent by a resident of Ohio.
To point out the uniqueness of the Obama campaign, Rep. Kyrsten Sinema, a Phoenix Democrat, said people were waiting outside for four hours or more to get inside. Lines began forming outside Invesco by early afternoon, and the field was packed just before Obama was to address the crowd.
Among those waiting eagerly was John Paul Bombe, a 23-year-old from Chicago, who said he likes Obama because “he’s in this election for the right reason — to get our country back on track instead of making him and his cronies rich.”
For a preview of the Republican National Convention and complete coverage of the Democratic National Convention, visit http://elections.azcapitoltimes.com/.
-Dolan Media writer Amy Gillentine contributed to this report.