Tag: doug ducey
State Supreme Court rejects GOP bid to void election
Legal challenges to election head to court
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Dissension in AZGOP as Trump dumps Ducey
Fiscal responsibility guiding AZ through tough times
I recently had the opportunity to hear from Richard Stavneak, director of the Joint Legislative Budget Committee, followed by revered economist Jim Rounds at the Arizona Tax Research Association’s highly anticipated annual Economic Outlook Conference and was pleasantly surprised to learn that Arizona is in better position economically than the rest of the country.
So why is Arizona thriving despite the adversity we are facing? Great public policy.
Despite an unexpected pandemic, Arizona was prepared for a fiscal downturn we didn’t see coming.
The state had approximately $1 billion in the rainy-day fund. That said, one might argue that most of this year would qualify as a “rainy day.”
If you look back, the state had also identified sustainable funding sources for vital services such as education.
Over the last half decade, Arizona has also increased dollars for priorities, while ensuring those programs are sustainable. In fact, in FY2004-FY2008 Arizona experienced an 11% average spending growth compared to FY2016-FY2020 when we saw only a 4.5% average spending growth in the state. Fiscal foresight and restraint played a key role in why Arizona is not suffering like other parts of the country.
Since the pandemic began, state revenue collections have been much higher (20%) than anticipated and as many states consider drastic budget cuts, Arizona ended the most recent fiscal year with a $370 million surplus. Instead of cutting, Arizona is investing in key areas like K-12, by infusing an additional $440 million for education in addition to funding already allocated in the FY2021 budget. That’s impressive given the current circumstances.
While recent years have seen significant investments in specific areas of the state’s budget that are important to Arizonans, much of these expenditures were wisely handled with one-time spending to avoid encumbering future Legislatures with fiscal obligations. When it came time to pass the “skinny budget” in May, much of the previous one-time spending was not included. There was not a fight that legislators were cutting programs, as would have been the case if these expenditures were made ongoing. It is also notable that it was resolved by a bipartisan effort.
Arizona can and must continue to implement great public policy in a fiscally responsible manner to remain prosperous going forward. As many states implemented harmful lockdowns, and are considering it again, Arizona has largely taken a commonsense approach. Critical industries like construction and manufacturing were allowed to continue operating safely, small business have remained nimble and creative in order to stay viable and Arizona businesses in general have remained resilient under one of the most adverse situations our state has ever experienced.
Arizona’s unemployment continues to remain below the national average and the state has regained 95% of the jobs that were lost during the spring months of 2020. Further, Arizona is in the top 5 in the nation for year-over-year job growth largely due to the governor’s “Open for Business” policies. Arizona’s housing market is one of the fastest growing in the nation. We must continue to remain vigilant and fiscally responsible. Arizona is obviously doing something right to be in this great position.
Steve Trussell became executive director of the Arizona Rock Products Association in 2007. He was also made director of the Arizona Mining Association in October of 2017.
Vote certified, GOP challenges continue
Kelly meets with Ducey as he prepares to take seat in Senate
4 mayors want statewide mask mandate, but don’t enforce their own
Get 24/7 political news coverage and access to events honoring top political professionals
Court tosses GOP lawsuit challenging election
A judge on Thursday removed the last legal hurdle to certifying the results of the election and handing the state’s 11 electoral votes to Joe Biden.
Maricopa County Superior Court Judge John Hannah, an appointee of former Gov. Janet Napolitano, denied the request by the Arizona Republican Party to block county supervisors from conducting a formal “canvass” to certify the votes. That clears the way for board action as early as Friday.
More to the point, Hannah summarily granted a bid by county supervisors to toss the entire case, a request that was joined by Secretary of State Katie Hobbs and the Arizona Democratic Party.
State GOP spokesman Zach Henry would not comment about a possible appeal.
But Thursday’s ruling is not the end of the debate about who won in Arizona.
At a press conference Thursday, Trump campaign attorney Rudy Giuliani promised a new major lawsuit in Arizona as well as one in the battleground state of Georgia, claiming to have “hundreds” of affidavits proving election fraud but declining to show them to reporters.
And state Rep. Mark Finchem, R-Oro Valley, counting on such a new lawsuit, is using that as a trigger to seek a special legislative session. He said the U.S. Constitution allows lawmakers to call themselves into session to look at voting in federal elections if there is evidence available — even from what has been filed in court — that there was fraud.
Separately, Senate President Karen Fann, R-Prescott, announced that the GOP caucus is setting up a special email account “to gather documented proof of voting irregularities in the 2020 general election in Arizona.”
Fann had previously said she wanted a look at what happened this year as a starting point for a future review of state election laws. Now, however, the Senate president wants these complaints by Nov. 27 — three days before the date set to formally “canvass” and certify the vote tally.
But Fann told Capitol Media Services it is not her intent to affect the canvass. Instead, she said, any credible information gathered would be passed along to the secretary of state or the attorney general.
And she dismissed the idea of a special session, saying it isn’t practical — or legal.
Finchem is working on a slightly different time line.
Federal law says that all disputes over presidential elections at the state level have to be resolved by Dec. 8. And the electors then cast their ballots six days later.
Finchem said if a legislative probe finds no evidence of fraud, then that clears the way for those electors to vote according to the will of the majority as shown by the election returns. Unofficial returns show Biden beat Trump by about 10,500 votes.
But Finchem said if a majority of the Republican-controlled legislature concludes that there was so much fraud as to make the results unreliable, they could block electors from casting their ballots for any candidate.
That, in and of itself, would not help Trump who, based on the latest numbers, has 306 electoral votes — including 11 from Arizona. He needs just 270 to win.
But it could prove crucial depending on possible legal — or legislative — action in other states.
In tossing the state GOP lawsuit, Hannah did not provide an immediate explanation for his ruling, promising more detail later. But he clearly indicated that he believes the lawsuit had no merit.
Hannah told Hobbs she can seek to recoup the legal fees she incurred in having to hire outside counsel to fight the lawsuit by the Republicans. And that is specifically based on a provision in Arizona law that requires judges to assess legal fees when someone files a claim “without substantial justification.”
Despite the ruling, GOP officials insist they are correct in their interpretation of the law — and the relief they sought — to require that there be a sampling of ballots for hand count from 2% of all voting precincts.
“We have identified problems in our own process where the will of a Democrat secretary of state is being substituted for the black letter law passed by the state legislature,” said Kelli Ward, who chairs the state GOP, in a prepared statement.
That is based on the fact that Arizona law requires there be an audit of voting through a hand count of ballots taken from 2% of the precincts.
But it was the Republican-controlled legislature that allowed counties to set up centralized “vote centers” instead where any individual from any precinct can cast a ballot. Six counties do that.
And that same law specifically gives the secretary of state the power to enact rules allowing audit samples to be drawn by vote centers and not individual precincts. Those rules, in turn, were approved by Gov. Doug Ducey and Attorney General Mark Brnovich, both Republicans.
Ward, however, maintains that something more needs to be done to verify the election results — and that Biden beat Trump — and to show that “only legal ballots were counted in the 2020 election.”
Editor’s note: This story has been revised to include more information.