By Abhay Padgaonkar, Guest Commentary//November 19, 2026//
(Pixabay)
By Abhay Padgaonkar, Guest Commentary//November 19, 2026//

More than three out of four people nationwide said the government is doing too little to regulate data centers.
As if to test that demand for action, Elon Musk’s SpaceX just announced plans for one of the country’s biggest data centers in Cochise County. At full buildout, it would need about 2.5 times more power than all Maricopa County data centers combined.
Arizona Democrats have scored a trifecta. Data center regulation is already shaping up as one of its first tests. They must now close the yawning gaps in current law that leave Arizonans at risk on utility costs, water, emissions, incentives, transparency, and corporate responsibility.
Stop the Bleeding First
In January, lawmakers must block billion-dollar, gigawatt-scale projects from front-running the accountability rules Arizona has failed to put in place.
Attorney General Kris Mayes has called for a pause on new data centers. Sen. Lauren Kuby says a potential moratorium is the “No. 1 policy initiative” legislative Democrats are examining.
Gov. Katie Hobbs initially rejected that approach, but said data centers must “pay for themselves,” not raise utility costs on Arizonans, and use water sustainably. Her office has now pledged to address communities’ “real concerns.”
That course correction is warranted. My cost-shift report found that $587 million was shifted away from a tiny group of extra-large customers and onto more than 1.4 million other APS customers.
Phoenix-area water use tied to powering data centers is projected to jump 400%, increasing water stress by up to 32% in affected basins when electricity-related consumption is counted.
APS says 5.8 gigawatts of demand is “committed or contracted,” with another 20-plus gigawatts in the queue. SRP and TEP also expect substantial large-load growth.
After the tax-break pause, more pending data center applications were approved than in the program’s entire previous life.
Craft the pause to work within Prop. 207, with parcel-specific waivers where needed, so projects cannot again slip under the wire before permanent rules take effect.
No More Cart before the Horse
Prove it: APS and the Corporation Commission have spent years chanting that “growth pays for growth” in unison without proving it.
Senate President-elect Priya Sundareshan says she looks forward to a more active legislative role, adding that “the Corporation Commission has abandoned its job, has abdicated its authority.” She also wants to codify “growth pays for growth.”
Under Republican control, the Legislature had made only a token effort. HB 2756 became law but provides for one-time cost studies only on request, preserves case-by-case utility latitude, and limits its explicit transaction-specific anti-subsidy showing to infrastructure.
It also excludes member-owned cooperatives such as AEPCO and SSVEC — the utilities tied to the SpaceX-driven Tombstone project.
SB 1380 went further but failed. It did not expressly mention purchased power or require project-specific proof before a deal.
Every large-load customer — whether served by an investor-owned utility, public-power entity, or electric cooperative — must pay all incremental costs it triggers and bear project-failure risk.
Before approval, an independent third party selected by the applicable regulator or governing body — not the utility or its hired guns — must publicly quantify generation, purchased-power, transmission, distribution, infrastructure, and abandonment costs.
The expert must attest that the analysis is technically defensible, and utility executives must certify under oath that the underlying data are complete and accurate.
APS says its latest TSMC contract protects customers from cost shifts. Make APS submit that claim to independent verification.
If a large-load contract fails to recover the full incremental costs it causes, Arizona law must ensure the utility — not captive customers — bears the shortfall.
Disclose it: Before approval, require disclosure of power demand and source, direct and electricity-related water demand and sources, generation-related emissions, infrastructure costs and who pays them, power-asset ownership, contract terms and asset lives, exit terms, stranded-asset risk, public incentives, and promised jobs and investment.
Tie public incentives to measurable promises on jobs, investment, and infrastructure, with clawbacks for material misses.
Require advance notice and a public hearing, preserve stronger local protections, and bar NDAs or redactions from defeating disclosure.
Require identification of the real company behind the project and every affiliate, shell, or project entity. Disclose who is legally bound, who guarantees the obligations, whose balance sheet backs them, whether that backing is sufficient, and how long it remains enforceable.
Require annual actual-versus-promised reporting. Standardize utility queue reporting to show megawatts requested, studied, financially secured, contracted, under construction, energized, withdrawn, canceled, and included in resource plans.
Prove it. Disclose it. Only then approve it.
Make Accountability the Law
Legislators cannot set utility rates. But they can and must require transparency, public accountability, and consequences.
Write enforceable accountability into law. Prove who pays, disclose the deal, independently verify costs, identify who is behind the project and whose balance sheet backs it, give affected communities a hearing, and enforce consequences when promises fail.
Private, redacted contracts between monopoly utilities and trillion-dollar corporate giants must not write Arizona’s energy policy.
That job belongs to the Legislature.
Abhay Padgaonkar is a management consultant and longtime consumer advocate who served as an expert witness on behalf of utility ratepayers in 2018.
You don't have credit card details available. You will be redirected to update payment method page. Click OK to continue.