Home / Election 2014 / Melvin misattributes Lincoln on class warfare

Melvin misattributes Lincoln on class warfare

Sen. Al Melvin, R-Tucson (Photo by Howard Fischer/Capitol Media Services)

Sen. Al Melvin, R-Tucson (Photo by Howard Fischer/Capitol Media Services)

Republican gubernatorial hopeful Al Melvin is using quotes from Abe Lincoln in his running fight with President Obama and his policies.

Only thing is, the 16th president never said the things Melvin claims he did about class warfare.

For example, in postings last week on Twitter, the state senator from Tucson wrote, “You cannot further the brotherhood of man by inciting class hatred.” That quote, Melvin said, came from Lincoln.

Ditto for a quote of, “You cannot help the poor by destroying the rich,” and “You cannot strengthen the weak by weakening the strong.”

But Brooks Simpson, a professor of history at Arizona State University, asked by Capitol Media Services about the quotes, said none of these came from Lincoln’s mouth or his pen.

“I can tell you that these quotes are spurious,” Simpson said. “They do not appear in Lincoln’s writings or in his recollected words.”

Melvin said he got the quotes from a Republican club newsletter.

“It sounded good,” he said. “It seemed like it was something that he would say.”

Told of the misattribution, Melvin said, “That’s news to me.”

Simpson said the comments are part of a series of statements by William J.H. Boetcker, made more than half a century after Lincoln was assassinated. In fact, Boetcker, a minister who toured the country, was not born until 1873.

“If anything, it’s an innocent mistake on my part,” Melvin said. The would-be governor said he liked the sentiment and wanted to be sure that no one thought he had made the statements himself.

“If Obama had said it, I would have credited him,” Melvin explained. “I know he wouldn’t have said it, but that was the point.”

Simpson said Melvin isn’t the first – and probably won’t be the last – to try to push an idea by putting the words into Lincoln’s mouth.

“I’m on the board of directors of the Abraham Lincoln Association,” he said. “By now, we are used to hearing quotes attributed to Lincoln by people who have not taken the time to verify them.”

Even after being informed of the professor’s comments, Melvin still was not ready to concede that perhaps he had not done his research prior to the tweets.

“I have no idea who he is or what his political leanings are,” Melvin said.

It would not have been necessary for the senator to consult an academician to raise questions in his mind about what he was posting. A casual search of the Internet with the quotes reveals multiple sites which question the authenticity of the quotes.

Despite that, Melvin apparently is not the only one to misattribute the quotes to Lincoln. Ronald Reagan did the same thing in his 1992 speech to the Republican National Convention.


  1. Is type of “got you” game really productive? Is an innocuous misquote in a club newsletter worth this much attention? Is there that much of a news shortage right now?

    State Representative John Kavanagh

  2. A familiar pattern can be seen among tea-chugging, spotlight-seeking conservative politicians and pundits:
    They lack the self-discipline to do their homework when publicly commenting on topics of historical or scientific significance. And so when in doubt, they simply make (stuff) up … and then audaciously suggest that the fallacy deserves more credence than the reality.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

Cattle graze along the East Verde River (Photo by Center for Biological Diversity)

Environmental group alleges cattle trashing river (access required)

Environmental groups have filed suit to remove most of the cattle off of 143 miles of the Verde River watershed.