Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Home / Featured News / Bill intends to penalize gross stunts with food

Bill intends to penalize gross stunts with food

A Texas woman in this 2019 video started a craze in which people lick ice cream on video and return the product to the shelf. Rep. T.J. Shope has proposed a law that would make it a felony to pull such a stunt.

A Texas woman in this 2019 video started a craze in which people lick ice cream on video and return the product to the shelf. Rep. T.J. Shope has proposed a law that would make it a felony to pull such a stunt.

It may be gross to take the lid off a quart of ice cream, lick it, and then put it back on the shelf of a grocery store.

But what it’s not, according to Rep. T.J. Shope, is illegal. So now the Coolidge Republican wants to make it a crime, one that, depending on the circumstances, could lend an offender in state prison.

That’s only one of the ways Shope is seeking to protect consumers.

A separate bill is aimed at those delivering food who, for whatever reason, decide it’s OK to sample what’s in the bag or box. HB 2298 would extend the requirements to get a food-handler’s license to those who work for private delivery services like Uber Eats and Postmates.

But Shope’s main focus is HB 2299.

He said there is a craze of sorts that apparently started last year with a girl taking a video of herself at a Texas store taking a container of ice cream off the shelf, licking it and the putting it back. What happened is it became a game of sorts – it picked up the informal name of the Blue Bell Challenge – with others seeking to follow suit and post their own videos.

There also are videos of people spitting into containers of ice tea and putting the containers back for others to buy.

Shope said he’s heard of one such incident in Arizona.

“It’s been our understanding that law enforcement has been unable to charge,” he said, as there is no specific law in Arizona that covers the situation. So his HB 2299, Shope said, is modeled after a law adopted in Texas.

As crafted, it would be a Class 2 misdemeanor to “knowingly introduce, add or mingle any bodily fluid, foreign object not intended for human consumption or unsanitary surface with any water, food, drink or other product that may be consumed by a human being.” Violators could end up in the county jail for up to four months and face a fine of $750.

But Shope said the focus of his bill is “these viral wanna-bes that are manipulating food products.”

So HB 2299 reserves its felony penalty – up to a year in state prison – for those who post photos or videos online of what they have done.

“People want to become the next Instagram hero of the day,” Shope said.

“It gets a bunch of clicks on a day,” he said. “And that makes somebody feel good, I guess.”

That same penalty also would apply if it turns out someone else ended up consuming the contaminated product.

Shope said the problem may not be limited to grocery stores.

“Places that have buffets have noticed some of this type of behavior as well,” he said. “So it runs the gamut.”

HB 2298 deals with a different kind of interaction between some people and food meant for someone else.

Last year US Foods, a major wholesale food distributor, conducted a survey of 1,518 people nationally who have food delivered by services like Uber Eats, Grubhub, DoorDash and Postmates as well as 497 who said they had worked for at least one of the food deliver apps.

It turns out that 21 percent of customers suspected drivers had sampled some of their food. But the problem actually is larger, with 28 percent of those who delivery admitting they had taken food from an order.

Shope’s solution: license these independent drivers the same way employees of restaurants already have to get certified as food handlers. That, he said, would instruct them on things like safe handling of food and preventing contamination.

Still, Shope conceded, nothing in that bill actually would keep a delivery driver from dipping into the fries or taking a sip of that milk shake. If nothing else, he said, it might make those on the delivery end at least “make a dent and make people feel more comfortable about what they’re eating at home.”

“I think the public needs a little peace of mind that at least their deliverers have been trained,” Shope said.

And Shope said now is the time to act.

“The craze, the direction, is definitely moving in that direction,” he said, with food delivery becoming more popular. “I use them as well.”

No date has yet been set for a hearing on either measure.


  1. Please use to circulate more news on HB 2270. Prisoners want to know it’s progress. Their families do too.

  2. Is the act of licking ice cream out of the container in the grocery store gross? Heck yeah. But making it the segway into prison over it is astounding.I don’t want my tax dollars supporting someone laying around behind bars because of something that’s stupid like this. The budget for the prison system is out of control as it is—why on earth do we continue to criminalize EVERYTHING?

  3. There should be a law on the books that allows police to charge stupid behavior that impacts our food supply. In the long view regulating stupidity is not a winning strategy. Better to focus on tamperproof containers.

    I am reminded of the adage … When you are dead … you don’t know that you are dead but everyone in your circle is affected. The same can be said for stupid people.

  4. Let’s hope the chairmen have enough sense to stop this foolish legislation. While the governor is wisely ridding the bureaucracy of cumbersome and unproductive obstacles for business and jobs, Rep. Shope attempts to add more.

  5. Kookooracharabioso

    Some diseases remain active despite freezing temperatures, including some untreatable life altering/threatening diseases. Some people who have acquired these life altering/threatening diseases want to make sure that other people suffer the same. Twisted, I know. Therefore I wholeheartedly endorse protecting our food supply and am happy to see that my favorite brand of ice cream now has a simple plastic band around the lid that they did not have prior to the “challenge.” Classes for food delivery persons isn’t going to change their behavior one iota (in my opinion) if they are so bent. Unfortunately we have a lot of perpetually bent people and often for consciously political reasons. No, I don’t accept food delivery unless it’s a family member who picks it up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Check Also

OSHA moves to strip state of ability to regulate worker safety

The federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration is moving to strip Arizona officials of their ability to regulate worker safety in Arizona because of the state's failure to immediately adopt emergency Covid health care rules to protect workers. 

/* code for tag */