Quantcast
Home / Opinion / Commentary / Patients should not be subjected to dubious medical practices

Patients should not be subjected to dubious medical practices

Governor Doug Ducey let down Arizona’s women when he signed Senate Bill 1318.

This anti-women’s health care law is egregious for many reasons, but its provision on so-called medical abortion reversal is tantamount to quackery.

Dr. Ilana Addis, chairwoman of the Arizona Section of the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists

Dr. Ilana Addis, chairwoman of the Arizona Section of the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists

The provision would require physicians to counsel their patients that a medication abortion can possibly be reversed once initiated; it also requires that the Arizona Department of Health Services website provide information on medication abortion reversal including referrals to physicians who claim to have success with this unproven practice.

The problem is that so-called medical abortion reversal is not FDA approved and has no good evidence to support it.

To have a medical abortion, a woman must take two drugs:  mifepristone, followed 48 hours later by misoprostol.  The advocates of abortion reversal claim that if a patient takes the first medication and wants to halt the process, then she would be referred to a physician who gives her high doses of progesterone to continue the pregnancy.

First, it should be noted that mifepristone, when taken alone, has a high failure rate, close to 50 percent. So among the rare women who might regret their decision, almost half would have their pregnancy continue without any additional medications. There is no data to show that high levels of hormones after this point would preserve the pregnancy.

Moreover, there are no good, evidence-based studies on using additional progesterone to reverse abortions. The “study” on which this law is founded involved only six women. Using that as a reference for treatment is dangerous and unscientific. In other words, it is bad medicine. The physicians who claim to do this also do not work from any standard protocols, and, if they give high doses of progesterone to these patients, they are not practicing according to the standard of care.

Women’s healthcare should be practiced by experts in the field and standards should be dictated by our national college.  Medical care should not be decided by legislators, and certainly not by the special interest groups who pushed this legislation.

Dr. Julie Kwatra, legislative chair of the Arizona Section of ACOG

Dr. Julie Kwatra, legislative chair of the Arizona Section of ACOG

It is blatantly wrong for the state of Arizona to force doctors to counsel their patients about voodoo medicine, and wrong for the Department of Health Services to sanction these practices by publishing this information on their website.

Facing an unwanted pregnancy is hard enough. The exceedingly rare woman who does regret her choice to terminate should not have to then be subjected to unproven doses of an unnecessary hormone and its related side effects.

Moreover, this law asks more questions than it answers. Is the patient going to bear the cost of this dubious treatment?  Will insurance companies and AHCCCS pay for up to 17 excess office visits and injections that are non-evidence based?

Abortion is an unfortunate fact of life.  What we all want is for it to be as rare as possible.  The evidence for that is indisputable:  Minimize unplanned pregnancies with comprehensive, evidence-based sexual education and access to contraception.

Not with junk science.

It is unfortunate that Arizona will continue to be a standard-bearer for unscientific treatment of women.

–Ilana Addis, M.D., is chairwoman of the Arizona Section of the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.  Julie Kwatra, M.D., is legislative chair of the Arizona Section of ACOG. 

3 comments

  1. As a Board Certified Ob/Gyn and a doc who believes that abortion should not be used for birth control – but can be used in cases of rape, incest, fetal malformations – I have to tell you that this bill and the Evidence backing this bill is Ridiculous – and I also checked on this “Dr Allan Sawyer” – this so called doctor is NOT a MD, and also is definitely NOT an Ob/Gyn so hence this doctor has absolutely no idea what he is doing – and there is absolutely NO way of reversing an abortion once you have medicated the start of the abortion because even if the medical abortion ‘fails’ – there is is Always an Extremely high risk of fetal anomalies – so honestly people – and especially those in the Arizona legislature – GET YOUR HEAD out of your A-S as my drill instructor use to tell me 30 years ago – and DO NOT PRACTICE MEDICINE from the legislature – that is NOT YOUR JOB. And, I am a REAL Ob/Gyn – you can look me up if you want.

  2. What an excellent article. “Tantamount to quackery” might be my new favorite descriptor.

    Extremists legislators in Arizona can’t get away with this- Keep fighting!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

 

x

Check Also

school-money-620

To feed Arizona’s starved public school system takes money, leadership

Arizona’s schools are starving, and the leadership within our business community is telling them, “Go eat cake.” Starvation won’t kill our schools all at once, but Arizona’s schools are gradually wasting away for want of less than one added penny.