Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Ethics overhaul looms at Corporation Commission amid recusal fights, staff firing

The official seal of the Arizona Corporation Commission. (Reagan Priest / Arizona Capitol Times)

The official seal of the Arizona Corporation Commission. (Reagan Priest / Arizona Capitol Times)

Ethics overhaul looms at Corporation Commission amid recusal fights, staff firing

Key Points:
  • Outgoing Chair Nick Myers wants to finalize ethics code revisions before leaving office
  • Stakeholders who helped write the code say they’ve heard nothing about the effort
  • Critics want changes to the code after a series of conflicts and controversies at the commission

After a raft of conflict-of-interest accusations, requests for recusals and staff disputes at the Arizona Corporation Commission, stakeholders, lawmakers and commissioners say it’s time for reforms.

The race for two seats on the ACC highlighted the continuing influence utility companies and other energy interests have over commission elections. And recent controversies over recusal requests and the firing of a commission policy advisor have also raised questions about how the ACC’s code of ethics should be enforced against commissioners and commission staff. 

Now, outgoing Commission Chair Nick Myers says he is hoping to finalize revisions to the code before leaving office in January.

“It is my hope to leave the Commission with a more solid foundation of professional guidelines that detail administrative enforcement actions related to violations of the Code of Ethics, as well as provide a clear roadmap for future amendments,” Myers said in a statement. 

Myers and Commissioner Kevin Thompson, both of whom ran unsuccessfully for reelection this year, were often targets of conflict-of-interest allegations, recusal requests and campaign finance complaints. But both commissioners maintain they will leave the ACC in a better place than they found it.

“It was total chaos, and so there’s some order that has been established,” Thompson said. “ I think my colleagues have done a tremendous job, all of us have, of getting the commission to where it is today, operating like an organization should be operating.”

But Diane Brown, the executive director of the Arizona Public Interest Research Group who helped the commission write its first code of ethics policy in 2018, said she isn’t aware of any discussions on changes to the code.

“From time to time, the commission has mentioned the code of ethics and areas that could be improved,” Brown said. “However, it’s news to me they are in the process of finalizing additional parameters on the code.”

Political donations

Myers noted that the original code of ethics was drafted after years of utility companies meddling in Corporation Commission elections.

“The ACC’s Code of Ethics was established in 2018, during a controversial election season when major companies heavily influenced Commission races,” Myers said. “The Code of Ethics was developed in a hurried environment with several Commissioners weighing in, and I believe the final product was very unclear and rushed as a result.”

But in 2026, utility companies are still influencing the races for commission seats, though maybe not as heavily now that most commission candidates run under the Citizens Clean Elections Commission’s public financing program. 

The Arizona Capitol Times found that individual utility company executives or staff members are still making contributions to commission campaigns. Additionally, outside groups spent over $2 million on the race for two seats this year, including $1.5 million to support Democrats Clara Pratte and Jonathon Hill. 

The ACC’s code of ethics prohibits commissioners from accepting donations from “any regulated public service corporation” and requires commissioners to either return those donations or recuse themselves from votes involving donors. However, the code of ethics does not govern independent expenditures made on behalf of a commission candidate but without their coordination.

“The code could be refined to explicitly state that a regulated utility making a contribution to an entity must have that entity agree that funding will not be used to influence a commission election,” Brown said. 

Or, the new Democratic majority in the state Legislature could take matters into their own hands. 

“There’s a general interest in transparency bills and looking at holding utilities accountable for their decisions related to ratepayer money,” said Sen. Lauren Kuby, D-Tempe.

She specifically referenced a bill introduced by Senate President-elect Priya Sundareshan, which would have prohibited regulated utilities from donating to political action committees or political nonprofits. Kuby — who will chair the Senate’s new Climate, Energy and Natural Resources Committee — said that proposal will likely reappear during the 2027 session.

Recusal fights

Since August, four different parties have asked Thompson and Myers to recuse themselves from the pending votes in the Arizona Public Service and Tucson Electric Power rate cases. 

All four requests — from the Arizona Free Enterprise Club, Attorney General Kris Mayes, consumer advocate Abhay Padgaonkar and the Arizona Solar Energy Industries Association — centered on public comments made by the two commissioners. 

Since the commission is a quasi-judicial body, its code of ethics strongly cautions commissioners against making public statements that could be seen as prejudicial. Additionally, the ACC abides by ex parte rules for utility rate cases, prohibiting all parties from communicating substantively about the case outside of the official docket. 

Autumn Johnson, the executive director of AriSEIA, said Thompson and Myers have frequently bucked that guidance by posting their opinions on social media or giving statements to reporters.

“Doing op-eds and making lots of public statements about things pending before the commission that are contested litigation is very concerning,” Johnson said. “This is the most I’ve ever seen of that.”

Johnson, Mayes and the Free Enterprise Club all argued that Thompson and Myers not only prejudged issues pending before the commission, but also publicly criticized the intervenors making those arguments. Padgaonkar went a step further, filing an ethics complaint against Thompson for publicly disavowing his analysis alleging APS is shifting the costs to serve data centers onto residential customers.

But the ACC’s code of ethics leaves recusal decisions to individual commissioners — allowing Thompson and Myers to reject all recusal requests filed against them. The two commissioners argued that their public statements had no bearing on their ability to preside impartially over either rate case. 

Additionally, the ACC’s own general counsel investigated and dismissed Padgaonkar’s ethics complaint against Thompson. But that attorney, Tom Van Flein, also serves as the commission’s ethics officer. Several stakeholders, and Van Flein himself, have argued against allowing the ACC’s general counsel to double up as its ethics officer. 

“The commission should consider adding in a provision that enables the majority of commissioners to vote to recuse another commissioner if there is a clear violation of the code of ethics,” Brown said. “And there is a strong case to be made to not have the ethics officer of the commission be the chief legal counsel, and instead to establish an independent panel to review complaints and make a recommendation.”

Staff disputes

Brown noted that when the ACC drafted its ethics code, several stakeholders urged commissioners to apply it to the ACC’s executive director and division heads as well. While commissioners didn’t heed the advice then, a recent staffing dispute and Myers’ hopes to stay at the ACC might prompt reconsideration. 

The commission is currently seeking two outside legal opinions after Executive Director Doug Clark fired Commissioner Lea Márquez Peterson’s policy advisor without her consent. Commission observers have questioned Clark’s authority to make that firing. 

“If the executive director can fire somebody who is a policy advisor and works for a commissioner, doesn’t that influence how that policy advisor might make recommendations?” said Amanda Ormond, an energy policy consultant with the Ormond Group. “That’s a really uncomfortable thing; you should not have an executive director who could influence the hiring and firing of staff, which influences what policy a staff member would recommend.”

To complicate matters further, Myers told the Arizona Capitol Times in October that he may be interested in returning to the commission as deputy executive director after his term ends in January. 

“It’s something I would be more than qualified to fill, and I would actually bring a great skill set to it,” Myers said. 

Nicole Garcia, the commission’s public information officer, said in a statement that the ACC is not currently hiring for the deputy executive director role. The position, which was originally coupled with the administrative services division director role, is still under organizational review. 

Nonetheless, some ACC observers say Myers’ consideration of the role warrants stronger ethics protections, whether from the commission itself or the Legislature.

“The voters of the state of Arizona did not return Chairman Myers to the commission, and to take a staff position flies in the face of what the voters wanted,” Ormond said. 

Brown, who said she would prefer the commission strengthen its policies without legislative intervention, argued any updates to the ethics code should consider extending its reach to staff members. 

“There have been enough issues of late to warrant the commission engaging in a discussion of whether staff should be included in the code and, if so, which staff and under what circumstances,” she said.

You don't have credit card details available. You will be redirected to update payment method page. Click OK to continue.