Rachel Leingang//June 17, 2015//
A small not-for-profit utility that mostly serves the city of Maricopa cut savings for solar by reducing net metering rates and adding a monthly fee for solar customers.
The utility, Electric District No. 3, also caps the number of people who can add solar panels at 30 per month.
ED3 serves about 23,000 customers in Pinal County. The district is a political subdivision of the state and is not regulated by the Arizona Corporation Commission. An elected board of directors voted to approve the changes to solar on May 27.
The rules will go into effect on July 1, but anyone who signs up before then will be grandfathered into the old solar program.
The utility has 793 solar customers, or about 3.45 percent of its customer base, which is the highest in the state, according to general manager Bill Stacy.
Stacy said the utility is losing out on fixed costs that solar customers don’t pay, a refrain echoed by utilities across the state that are asking the Corporation Commission for added solar fees or changes to net metering.
After Salt River Project announced its plans to assess a demand charge on solar users, which averages about $50 per month, solar companies flocked to ED3 territory, Stacy said. Since January, installations skyrocketed to about 70-80 per month, he said.
A chart from ED3 shows about 250 solar customers as of December 2014, shooting up to nearly 800 as of May.
The utility estimates $730 in unrecovered fixed costs for each solar customer, totaling a loss of $579,000 in 2015.
“We’re trying to be fair to everyone, and we’re trying to work with solar. We don’t have a problem with solar. We’re just trying to get them to pay their fair share or as close as they can to it,” Stacy said.
ED3 added a solar fee of $21 for an average solar customer, which is the same as the fee Arizona Public Service is asking the Corporation Commission to approve.
In addition, ED3 changed net metering rules for excess energy. Under the old rules, a customer who generated excess energy would be compensated at the full retail rate for that power. The new rules will drop that down to the utility’s avoided cost rate of 2.6 cents per kilowatt-hour, or the amount it would have paid for energy from other sources.
The change is similar to requests from Tucson Electric Power and two electric cooperatives, which asked the Corporation Commission to lower the net metering rate.
The net metering changes will reduce savings by about $10-20 per month, the utility says.
ED3 hasn’t raised its rates on standard customers in six years, Stacy said.
“We’re real concerned about rates. … We want to keep rates very stable for our customers. We’re concerned that this (cost shift) can impact our rates,” he said.
SunHarvest Solar founder Brandon Cheshire said his company had just hired and started training a salesperson to target the Maricopa area, but the company canceled the plan after ED3’s announcement.
“We’re still going to explore that market, but it’s not going to be as aggressive of an exploration. … They basically chopped our feet off,” Cheshire said.
The move to add a fee coupled with substantial cuts to net metering is unprecedented and will likely stymie the industry in that area, Cheshire said. But the changes would not be as impactful in the larger picture of Arizona solar as SRP’s demand charge due to the size of the utility, he said.
“It’s just a grab at trying to save their profits. … It’s an unwillingness to adapt to their customer base,” Cheshire said.
Sean Monaghan, chief operating officer of PEP Solar, said if SRP’s demand charge was detrimental, ED3’s changes “take it to a whole new level.” Monaghan said he’s been getting lots of calls from people asking about the changes as the cutoff date approaches.
Monaghan said the changes just show how the utilities in Arizona aren’t friendly to solar.
“This train has left the station. There’s no stopping (solar). What they’re really doing is excluding themselves from the future,” Monaghan said.
The city of Maricopa’s mayor, Christian Price, has a mid-sized solar system on his house and will be grandfathered into the old rates, but he estimates he would have paid $26 per month more under ED3’s new solar program.
“Would I still do it? I think for $26 a month, I think I would,” Price said.
Price said he’s heard from Maricopa residents who aren’t happy with the changes, and he wishes everyone could have the old rates, but that would have an adverse effect on the utility.
“The company has to function. With everybody going solar, there’s still a use on the grid that I think a lot of people don’t understand,” Price said.
The changes to ED3’s solar program will likely quell the flood of solar applications, Price said, but are a healthy move for the utility in the long term.
“We certainly worry about all users. We want to be sure that everybody is treated fairly. … That’s the balancing game we all have to play here,” Price said.
You don't have credit card details available. You will be redirected to update payment method page. Click OK to continue.