Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Home / Featured News / Ducey, legislative leaders cave to pressure on ‘sanctuary city’ bill

Ducey, legislative leaders cave to pressure on ‘sanctuary city’ bill

Gov. Doug Ducey and GOP leadership in the House and Senate have killed a controversial ballot referral that would have asked voters to amend the state Constitution to ban sanctuary jurisdictions after the legislation sparked sharp criticism and mounting protest.  

House GOP Spokesman Andrew Wilder confirmed Thursday evening that Republican leadership in both legislative chambers and the office of Gov. Doug Ducey jointly decided to pull the referral from tomorrow’s House Judiciary Committee hearing, and pledged not to consider the twin bills sponsored by Rep. T.J. Shope, R-Coolidge, and Sen. Sylvia Allen, R-Snowflake.

“We can confirm that legislation related to a constitutional ban on sanctuary cities will not receive additional consideration this session — a decision made jointly by legislative leadership and the Governor,” Wilder said over text. “Sanctuary cities are illegal in Arizona. It will remain that way, and our members will remain vigilant to keep these bad policies out of Arizona.”

The proposal was one of many of Ducey’s legislative priorities. 

“The Governor stands firmly with the people of Arizona in opposition to sanctuary cities — a California-style policy rejected overwhelmingly by voters in Tucson last fall,” Ptak said. “The Governor is appreciative of Representative Shope’s leadership on this issue, and while these proposals will not be moving forward, the state of Arizona will continue to oppose any effort to create sanctuary cities.”

The referral would ask voters to determine whether the Arizona Constitution should prevent local jurisdictions from limiting their collaboration with federal immigration officials — effectively elevating a portion of the state’s 2010 immigration bill, SB1070, to the Constitution.

Allen said she was not informed that her bill would be killed this session and said she would place a call with the governor’s office. Shope did not immediately return request for comment. 

It’s unclear what resulted in the bills dying, though one Republican, Rep. Tony Rivero of Peoria, told the Legislative Report Thursday he would likely not vote for the referral, putting it on life support. With the House’s split of 31 Republicans and 29 Democrats, any single Republican can effectively stop the majority from moving its priorities forward. 

Rep. John Allen, R-Scottsdale, the chair of the House Judiciary Committee, could not be reached for comment. 

“This is great news,” said Rep. Diego Rodriguez, D-Phoenix, a key Democrat on the committee.


  1. Stopping sanctuary cities in Arizona, what a rash concept!

    They don’t have sanctuary cities for Guatemalans in Mexico, and they aggressively remove them when they come over illegally into Mexico.

  2. The fairly recent mood in Maricopa County and Pima County had been to adopt Sanctuary type policies for their field law enforcement activities. That was until the voting in Pima County/Tucson defeated such a Sanctuary proposal at the ballot box by more than two to one. That those adopted policies were in conflict with State Law as in SB-1070 was well known yet not only were the Sanctuary jurisdictions not challenged at the State level Governor Ducey approved of giving state resident tuition to illegal aliens as affirmed by Board of Regents in direct violation of law. It wasn’t until the lopsided vote against Sanctuary Cities in Pima County that the conventional wisdom went out the window and a few state leaders saw the light being shined by the voters. This is lawlessness at work and is a problem at the State and National level and is prevalent with issues impacting immigration. Once you start down the lawless path it is relatively easy to filter over into other areas primarily implemented by elected officials through fiat and extralegal means.

  3. Oh yeah…. so endth the persistent myth the Republican Party controls Arizona. Now if you think they can’t turn the ‘Grand Canyon State’ into the Land of Entrapment in no time flat, I have some Carolina swampland you might interested in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

Good revenues belie looming budget uncertainty (access required)

With COVID-19 again on the rise in Arizona and the next legislative session looming, some in the Legislature are coming around to the idea of passing a so-called “skinny budget” that retains baseline spending levels from the previous fiscal year and ducking out early, just as lawmakers did last session.

/* code for tag */