Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

High court to consider fairness of method to raise water rates

Rachel Leingang//February 10, 2016//

High court to consider fairness of method to raise water rates

Rachel Leingang//February 10, 2016//

water-flow-620

The Arizona Supreme Court will hear a case about a mechanism used by water companies to increase rates outside of a rate case.

The Court of Appeals previously ruled the system improvements benefit was unconstitutional. It allows water companies to increase rates for adding infrastructure.

The court’s eventual ruling could have wider implications, since many utilities use rate adjustments, affecting millions of Arizona customers, that could come under scrutiny if the SIB is ruled unconstitutional.

The state’s Residential Utility Consumer Office contends the Arizona Corporation Commission’s mechanism doesn’t meet the Arizona Constitution’s requirement to find the “fair value” of public service corporations’ property when setting rates.

The benefit allowed water companies to increase rates by up to 5 percent each year for five years between rate cases. The mechanism was intended to help water companies replace aging infrastructure. Typically, companies pay money up front to upgrade or add infrastructure and recoup the money in rates after the fact.

In arguments before the appellate court, RUCO attorney Dan Pozefsky said a 5 percent rate increase annually for five years would be more than a utility would normally get during a rate case. The commission “essentially gutted fair value” when it came up with the benefits, Pozefsky told the court.

After the Court of Appeals ruling, RUCO director David Tenney said the case could have broad implications, beyond just water companies, for other adjustments that utilities use when setting rates.

RUCO filed suit against the Corporation Commission and several water companies who were granted system improvement benefits by the commission, though the suit against Arizona Water Company was the first to go before the appellate court. After the Court of Appeals ruling, Arizona Water Company and the Corporation Commission both filed petitions for review to the Arizona Supreme Court, which granted the review Tuesday.

The Corporation Commission has said the Constitution is intentionally vague about how the commission is supposed to determine fair value. Its attorney, Wes Van Cleve, told the appellate court there was “no instruction manual” for the commission’s ratemaking authority.

Corporation Commission spokeswoman Angie Holdsworth said the commission is “pleased that the court decided to hear this matter.”

Tenney told the Arizona Capitol Times RUCO suspected the Supreme Court would grant the review and has been prepared to argue against the benefit.

“We’re not surprised, given the magnitude of this case. … It has the potential to touch any Arizonan,” Tenney said.

When rates are decided piecemeal and commissioners only look at one aspect of costs, ratepayers aren’t protected, Tenney said.

“Then we can get a runaway train here, and rates could skyrocket without the safeguards that are in place to determine what is fair to the ratepayers,” he said.

The Arizona Supreme Court ordered the case be set for oral arguments. Parties to the case were directed to file briefs within 20 days.

No tags for this post.

Subscribe

Get our free e-alerts & breaking news notifications!

You don't have credit card details available. You will be redirected to update payment method page. Click OK to continue.