Home / courts / Judge: Rapist should pay $10M to Arizona prison teacher

Judge: Rapist should pay $10M to Arizona prison teacher


A federal magistrate is recommending that a convicted sex offender who raped an Arizona prison teacher be ordered to pay her $10 million in punitive and compensatory damages, court records show.

The woman who was raped inside a prison classroom in January 2014 has already received a $3 million settlement from the state.

The rape led to an overhaul of security arrangements for Arizona prison teachers and other unsworn staff members. They were issued pepper spray, cameras were placed in classrooms and the frequency of security checks was increased.

There’s little chance of collecting from Jacob Harvey if U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton accepts the recommendation from the magistrate, said her attorney, Scott Zwillinger. But he could inherit money or receive cash from his tribe, which owns several Arizona casinos.

Harvey presented no defense and refused to participate in court hearings, leading to the magistrate John Z. Boyle’s Aug. 3 recommendation that a default judgment be entered against him.

Harvey was just 20 and in the first year of a 30-year term for raping a suburban Phoenix woman when he assaulted the teacher. Last year, he was sentenced to life in prison after pleading guilty to raping the teacher.

“Yes, he’s been sentenced to prison for the rest of his life, but this is a different part of justice,” Zwillinger said. “He might be entitled to money going forward — whether that’s from the tribe, from a family member or something else.

“He’s not likely to get out of prison, but who knows, and he should have to pay for what he did whether that’s now or 25 years from now.”

The Associated Press has not named the teacher because she is a victim of a sexual assault, but in interviews with the AP she blamed the corrections department for not protecting her. In a letter her lawyer read at Harvey’s sentencing, she said she remained traumatized by the event.

“At one point after the rape I wished inmate Harvey had just killed me because death seemed like a relief compared to the hell I was living,” her statement said. “While I may have wanted to die shortly after the rape, I now have a greater purpose and will to live.”

Harvey is a member of the Tohono O’Odham tribe, which operates several casinos. The southern Arizona tribe has in the past distributed cash from casino earnings to enrolled members, although it hasn’t done so in years.

The state’s workplace safety agency, knows as the Arizona Industrial Commission, fined the Corrections Department $14,000 for failing to protect the teacher. The department appealed and in a settlement reached early this year, the Commission waived the fine because prison officials said they had spent $600,000 on security improvements. The Corrections Department did not admit wrongdoing.

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

One comment

  1. Arizona is known for its lacking workplace safety. “in interviews with the AP she blamed the corrections department for not protecting her.” Arizona corrections and nursing fields typify the lack of mandated staffing ratios recognized, enacted and enforced by other states. The few worker protections that law provides Arizona workers are rarely enforced by paper tiger agencies whose ultimate goal is to ignore or settle these issues away rather than enforce any actual deterrent that would have protected the teacher beforehand. Attorneys for the employers and for the agencies in Arizona know that rarely allowing or upholding worker protection statutes creates a climate where workers safety and rights remain at risk, and wrongdoing is never admitted.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also


Gov. Doug Ducey rolls out school safety package

Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey wants more school resource officers and school mental health spending, a new way to remove guns from unstable people and technology fixes to get state convictions into the federal gun background check system faster.