Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Home / Opinion / Commentary / Cities simply need to enforce good neighborhood policy

Cities simply need to enforce good neighborhood policy

Paradise Valley Mayor Bien-Willner is wrong.  Cities have all the authority they need to enforce good neighborhood policy.

Rep. Kavanagh’s HB2481 is too much regulation and not needed. The laws are already on the books and have been for a long time.  These laws enable cities to restrict and enforce noise, nuisance, or neighborhood disturbances.  The cities and towns simply need to do their job and enforce the laws.

There is no problem that can’t be solved by working together. Airbnb, Expedia/VRBO, and Arizona Vacation Rental Association (AVRA) are working and talking with cities and short-term rental owners to ensure a “good neighbor” policy is followed by all.

To set the record straight, data show that so-called “bad actors” and “party houses” make up less than one-tenth of one percent of all STR activity. To put this into perspective, this means that 99.9% of short-term rental owners are good neighbors, operate responsibly, quietly, and have few complaints. We are working proactively to encourage these practices. Airbnb recently shut down 50 “party houses” that had received regular and repeated complaints. Several of these were in Scottsdale and Paradise Valley. Should we kill 99.9% to go after the 1%? No! We should not.

We, the industry platforms and AVRA, have connected with many short-term rental owners and we are in communication, urging better practices and policing of their properties. We all recognize that these short-term rental owners are in neighborhoods, and it puts an added responsibility to ensure good behavior by patrons. The short-term rental industry’s economic impact is big, and it is significant. Short-term rental owners are concerned and want to avoid potential problems. They have reached out to us and we’re communicating regularly. We are meeting with city councils, mayors and police departments. We discuss with them how the industry is working to be good neighbors. We discuss the economic impact and share how the rental process works.

The plain truth is short-term rental patrons are predominantly families coming to enjoy everything that makes Arizona special. They’ve been doing it since before Frank Lloyd Wright build Taliesin West – and my father, Sen. Barry Goldwater, would’ve recognized that.

Short-term rental owners are local residents and small business people who collectively are the people who build and grow Arizona for the future. HB2481 would penalize, restrict or completely put these short-term rental owners out of business during a pandemic, which has already destroyed so many small Arizona businesses.

Barry Goldwater, Jr.

Barry Goldwater, Jr.

Arizona was forward-thinking when Gov. Doug Ducey signed SB1350, the “Home Sharing Act,” into law in 2016, protecting private property owners’ constitutional rights to operate their property as rentals. Sen. Goldwater, my father, believed in the Constitution that protects property rights.

Worldwide, Arizona is known for its friendly atmosphere. We are easy-going, with a healthy business climate, beautiful sunsets and weather. Snowbirds flock to Arizona for world-class golf, spring training, major league baseball, basketball, football and hockey. New businesses and families are relocating to Arizona from blue states because of high taxes and onerous regulations. It’s no secret why people choose to stay in an Arizona short-term rental property.

Annually, Arizona has 10 million visitors. 30% of those visitors choose to stay at a short-term rental property. Annually, over $3 billion is spent by visitors. The short-term rental industry pays $350 million in tax revenue to Arizona and supports over 40,000 Arizona jobs. It is a giant economic engine that is vital to sustaining and growing Arizona’s economy. We do not need more regulation. We need the Mayor of Paradise Valley to enforce the rules already on his town’s books.

It may come as a surprise to most of us that cities like Gilbert, Glendale, Goodyear, Lake Havasu City, and Prescott have hundreds of short-term rentals operating in their municipalities today. These patrons are pumping vital economic life into these cities at a time when they need it most. This segment of the economy can be expected to see continued growth, benefitting every part of Arizona.

There is no need for different rules for private property simply because they are short-term rentals, which would infringe upon the constitutional rights of Arizonans. This would be a “conservative conscience” that father would proclaim and embrace.

If tourism is important to Arizona, then short-term rentals are important to Arizona tourism. We do not need more regulations, but cities need to enforce the laws that are already on their books. I urge members of our State Legislature to oppose HB2481 with their full strength and might.

Barry M. Goldwater, Jr., a retired member of the U.S. Congress, is a founder of Arizona Vacation Rental Association.


  1. Mr. Goldwater your father would be disgusted with your actions. I’m all for property rights. However, come walk in my families shoes! With an AirBnb in our backyard, gone is the friendly chats with our long time neighbor. Now, every 3 to 5 days we have new transient guests – every day is a Friday, of course, they are on vacation. Screaming, yelling, TV and music on full blast. Drunk shenanigans, until all hours of the morning. We live in a neighborhood, not a hotel. If these actions were going on at a hotel they would be warned and then removed from the property. Now it’s my job to police this house? As the out of state owner tells me just let me know?? Not my job. We just want the peace, tranquility, and enjoyment of our property back. As for them bringing in revenue- it actually costs our state tax revenues, bed tax is much less than hotel tax. Short term renters don’t eat out, they eat in the home. This hurts our restaurant industry. I’m all for property rights. However, advertising the 3 bedroom house behind us for up to 12 guests is not the answer. If my previous neighbor had 12 guests over it was just fine. 3, 5, 7 day STR’s not so much. We need to have occupancy limits and minimum stay limits. If these properties don’t follow those rules along with noise, traffic, garbage, etc. the owner needs to be fined a significant amount daily, no cap! For these out of state investors, they don’t care. It’s a business and about the bottom line. I urge you to come to my home and spend a weekend and see the debauchery we live with daily. Please come. Just like the owner of the property, I’m sure you will ignore this request as well. STRs as we know them today need to be changed for the betterment of our neighborhoods and communities. May you wake up and listen and recognize the destruction to our quality of life and stop lining your pockets.
    Frustrated Scottsdale Resident

  2. Mr. Goldwater, of course this would be your opinion since you represent the Arizona Vacation Rental Association. It is a shame you can’t be more objective. Commercially operated short term rentals in a residential neighborhood are simply not compliant with zoning use regulations, and the State of Arizona has blocked cities from enforcing these laws. I am quite sure you would not support a Motel 6 built next door to your private residence, where Mr. Tom Bodett would leave the light on for you all night long. Do you really think people will buy your weak argument? I certainly don’t.

  3. I wish a short term rental would move in next to you…You would change your tune real quick…They allow way too many people inside the STR’s and then it spills out into the back yard, where they usually invite over their friends and pretty soon therre is all kinds of noise for us neighbors…The police have told us they can’t do anything about it…So how can you say the cities have the power to do something about it…Again…Our neighborhook has gone to hell in a hand basket and you will never understand until one is next door to you…That will be my prayer…God works in strange and mysterious ways.

  4. Your views and motivations have nothing to do with property rights, conservatism, or fairness. Your organization and others like it, including the platforms you leverage, have thrown countless man-hours and lobbying dollars towards the goal of robbing citizens of local control in their communities. Everything you advocate is code for “make money”, all at the expense of the formerly cohesive, safe neighborhoods you gleefully destroy in the pursuit of the almighty dollar. These hotels in home’s clothing are devastating entire cities, and you know it, but as long as y’all are raking it in you simply don’t care. Was your father a sociopath as well? Only so long you can skate on his name before people realize what you’re really made of. The root of all evil truly is money, which animals like yourself worship as a God. I wish you could see the faces of the folks in my community that have literally been forced out of their neighborhoods due to the flood of short-term rentals destroying the peace and character of the communities their presence helped build. Most of them elderly, many of the veterans. This is their reward for a life well-lived: To be shafted in their Golden Years by a money-grubbing Goldwater shyster. Here’s hoping your Type A personality leads to a fatal heart attack in the very-near future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

holidays, Thanksgiving, Christmas, unity, election, rhetoric

Time to change your tune

Memorable tunes begin around Thanksgiving, and their words ignite peace, joy, and happiness to all who listen.