Home / Opinion / Commentary / A losing strategy: Arizona is not an ice cream shop

A losing strategy: Arizona is not an ice cream shop

Gov. Doug Ducey delivers his inaugural address Jan. 5 at  the state Capitol.  (Capitol Media Services photo by Howard Fischer)

Gov. Doug Ducey delivers his inaugural address Jan. 5 at the state Capitol. (Capitol Media Services photo by Howard Fischer)

Our new governor has been sworn into office and the legislative session has begun.

We know that Arizona’s budget is facing a $1 billion shortfall and the state has been court-ordered to pay $317 million to schools. We also know that while other states are rebounding from the recession, Arizona’s employment rate and economic recovery continue to lag behind others.

During his State of the State address, Governor Doug Ducey committed to more of the same. There will be no new revenues, no delay of corporate tax cuts, nor a temporary way to deal with the $1 billion budget deficit. “Not on our watch,” he said.

Our new governor likes sports analogies so I will describe his address as being cut from the same three decades old Republican playbook – a losing strategy that has prevented Arizona from performing at a championship level.

During last week’s Chamber of Commerce presentation, Republican Senate President Andy Biggs accused Democrats of not being good cheerleaders. Does he really think that if we just adopted a more rah-rah attitude this pesky $1 billion deficit would disappear? There aren’t enough pom-poms in the state to do that.

Democrats will not stand on the sidelines and cheer for bad game plans. The Republican vision of an improved economy based upon a conservative economic philosophy has never materialized. The harm to our children is immediate and real.

Despite his campaign pledges to ensure opportunity through education, Governor Ducey doubled down on what doesn’t add up: Starving government at the expense of our schools does not, nor will it lead to a major league economy.

The governor can and should scout out other states to expand his economic playbook. Do Arizonans want investment in a competitive, knowledge-based economy or do they want to starve government at the expense of our health, safety and opportunity? Does Governor Ducey want the economic success of the state of Washington or the economic failure of the conservative tax policies of the state of Kansas?

Arizona is not an ice-cream shop. Governor Ducey should not be franchising bad ideas.

Successful business leaders know investing in their people is key to economic growth. Will businesses want to locate or stay in a state with poor performing schools? Will employers want to locate in a state where workers lack the job skills needed to compete?

Recent legislatures have given so many tax cuts and tax credits to special and corporate interests that we can’t meet our legal obligation to appropriately fund schools.  The subsequent cuts to public education have been so deep that large class sizes and low salaries are driving good teachers from the classroom. Students are shortchanged; just seven of every 100 who enter elementary school graduate from a four-year college.

Unfortunately, Governor Ducey and the Legislature seem more concerned with waitlists for charter schools than providing the infrastructure of opportunity to the 85 percent of Arizona students who attend traditional public schools now.

Additionally, there was not a word about universities in this week’s address. Ominous? Attempting to balance the budget by further slashing funds to our universities would be disastrous to Arizona families who can’t afford additional tuition increases.

Back to the sports analogies. If Governor Ducey wants to lead a thriving state to its potential, he’ll need to be a more innovative leader, an actual game changer. Democrats want to help solve our state’s problems and offer to join him in the clubhouse to help come up with a winning game plan.

Coaching great Vince Lombardi once said, “Individual commitment to a group effort – that is what makes a team work, a company work, a society work, a civilization work.”

We agree.

 – Bill Roe is chairman of the Arizona Democratic Party.


  1. “Starving government at the expense of our schools does not, nor will it lead to a major league economy.”

    First, given the money being spent locally and nationally on education, one would expect better results. It’s really shallow to claim that more money will address the gaps in education. School districts have brought much of this on themselves with the idiotic power structure that focuses on administrators instead of teachers. Start there before crying about money.

    Second, a major league economy will not result from ensuring that the state and local governments starve the private sector for capital. There’s no jobs without private investment first and Arizona lags behind states like Nevada, Texas, and Florida for its lack of business-friendly environment. The most you can say is that Arizona is at least not suffering flight of jobs the way that California and New York are.

  2. “Who is easier to silence than a child?” – J K Rowling

  3. It appears the Ducey budget reflects more of the same and we are disappointed in his commitment to education. Education and health are critical to a healthy and robust society and this is where Ducey will make cuts. Does he not get it? Corporate tax cuts, given by the past legislatures, must be rescinded. The state needs to maintain current revenue levels and cannot afford to give revenue away to corporations. Corporations can afford to pay taxes as most are already raising new corporate revenues by passing on costs to do business to consumers or not hiring. What is our new Governor thinking? Keep the revenue we have and seek ways to make new revenue. Giving monies away to prisons instead of education is not prudent and this is what he is doing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

Medical Concept: Black Chalkboard with Abortion. Medical Concept - Abortion Handwritten on Black Chalkboard. Top View Composition with Chalkboard and Red Stethoscope. 3D Rendering.

O’Halleran, Kelly must support born-alive protections

Infanticide has no place in our society – not in Arizona or anywhere in America. We hope every constituent will contact their legislators today and urge them to support the Born-Alive Act.

/* code for tag simpli.fi */