Home / environment / Navajo Nation sues feds over massive 2015 mine waste spill

Navajo Nation sues feds over massive 2015 mine waste spill

The Animas River runs yellow with toxin-tainted wastewater that was accidentally released from the abanoned Gold King Mine near Durango, Colorado. (Photo by Colorado Parks and Wildlife Department via Reuters)

The Animas River runs yellow with toxin-tainted wastewater that was accidentally released from the abanoned Gold King Mine near Durango, Colorado. (Photo by Colorado Parks and Wildlife Department via Reuters)

Leaders of one of the nation’s largest American Indian tribes blasted the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency as their attorneys sued Tuesday, claiming negligence in the cleanup of a massive mine waste spill that tainted rivers in three Western states.

Navajo Nation President Russell Begaye stood on the bank of the San Juan River in northwestern New Mexico and explained his people’s link to the water and the economic, cultural and psychological damage inflicted in the wake of the August 2015 spill in southwestern Colorado.

“EPA, we’re holding your feet to the fire,” Begaye said, promising that generations of Navajos are willing to fight. “We will not let you get away with this because you have caused great damage to our people, our river, our lifeblood.”

A federal contractor triggered the spill during preliminary cleanup work at a mine near Silverton, Colorado. Three million gallons of wastewater carrying arsenic, lead and other heavy metals contaminated rivers in Colorado, New Mexico and Utah.

Communities downstream were forced to temporarily halt drawing water from the Animas and San Juan rivers for drinking water and irrigation.

Officials have estimated some 880,000 pounds of metals poured into the rivers. Navajos and others are concerned the contamination that has settled in the riverbeds and banks is getting stirred up each time storm runoff courses downstream.

The EPA has taken responsibility for cleaning up the spill, but a spokeswoman said Tuesday that the agency will not comment on pending litigation.

The Navajo Nation joins New Mexico in pursuing legal action over the spill. The state sued the EPA and Colorado earlier this year, citing environmental and economic damage.

Tribal officials at the news conference and in the lawsuit pointed to delays and resistance by the EPA, saying the agency has failed to compensate Navajos for their losses or provide any meaningful recovery efforts over the past year.

The EPA has dedicated more than $29 million to respond to the spill and for monitoring, but much of that is going toward stabilization and ongoing drainage at the mine. Reimbursement of state, local and tribal costs is underway, but the tribe has received only a fraction of the nearly $1.6 million doled out to all the parties.

Begaye said Navajo farmers have felt the brunt of the spill. Some crops went unplanted this year and cultural practices such as the gathering of corn pollen were skipped.

“We have seen the tears. We’ve heard the cries. We’ve heard the anger, the anguish, the loss of trust,” Begaye said.

He called the actions of the agency, its contractor and the mining companies reckless and reiterated his disappointment that Navajos have yet to receive a phone call or letter of apology from President Barack Obama.

Navajo officials said the government has denied repeated requests for everything from compensation for farmers to resources for long-term monitoring and an onsite laboratory for real-time testing of the river.

“They have not done a thing,” Begaye said during his impassioned address.

While the lawsuit doesn’t include an exact dollar figure for damages the tribe is seeking, Begaye said Navajos are owed “millions” and that the scope of the contamination is still unknown.

A criminal investigation into the spill is being conducted by the EPA’s Office of Inspector General and the U.S. Justice Department, but it’s unclear how long that probe could take.

Several members of Congress had pressed for an investigation into the EPA’s role in causing the disaster.

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


  1. http://www.cpr.org/news/story/gold-king-mine-1887-claim-private-profits-and-social-costs

    Worth reading Colorado Public Radio for the full explanation! By the time other news outlets get done with this story you would think the EPA took a pristine area and all by themselves created an environmental disaster.

    Reality is a convoluted 100+ year old series of events and total lack of private, business and state of Colorado accountability resulting in polluted waters for over 100 years. The last person standing is the EPA and in their efforts to fix the mess they accidentally breach a sieve of a “debris dam” waiting to break anyway and holding back millions of gallons of contaminated water. And now the check book is open for every real or perceived slight and all US tax payers have to foot the bill? This is nuts!

  2. Anyone who has dealt with EPA can appreciate how heavy a hand they have, and how much they demand of others. Now they have a very public event in which they were in charge, and they need to meet the same requirements they would require of others.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

Private Prison

Arizona prisons up number of sanitary napkins for inmates

The Arizona Department of Corrections on Tuesday said it would immediately triple the number of free sanitary napkins it automatically provides each month to female inmates as it works to head off a Democratic proposal in the Legislature to provide unlimited free tampons, pads and other feminine hygiene products.