Home / Opinion / Commentary / Russell Pearce has gone too far

Russell Pearce has gone too far

I am saddened and outraged by Russell Pearce’s latest efforts to legislate bigotry and discrimination into Arizona law.

As first reported in the Arizona Capitol Times, Sen. Pearce is now attempting to deny citizenship to American-born children if their parents are illegal immigrants, and to deny public education to undocumented children by requiring them to pay tuition or be forced out of school.

To say Pearce has gone too far is a gross understatement.

I support securing our borders and fixing our immigration system with tough but fair reform that works, including cracking down on employers who hire illegal immigrants and requiring illegal immigrants currently here to register with the government, pay a fine and back taxes to get right with the law, have no other criminal record, and maintain gainful employment.

I am against illegal immigration. Having grown up on the border, I’ve seen first hand the consequences of both illegal immigration and criminal trafficking.

That said, Pearce’s attacks on children, the Constitution, and our fundamental American principles of fairness and justice are beyond the bounds of human decency. They are downright offensive.

I call on Pearce to immediately drop his crusade against immigrant communities.

As the Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. reminded us in his letter from a Birmingham Jail in 1963, “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.”

What Pearce proposes is a grave injustice. If enacted, it threatens not only Arizona, but our fundamental American values.

The 14th Amendment clearly states, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens…” The Supreme Court rejected Pearce’s view as unconstitutional more than 100 years ago, but ideologues conveniently ignore the Constitution when it restricts their agenda. They resort instead to name-calling and race-baiting, using degrading and inaccurate terms like “anchor babies” to cloud the debate.

The 14th Amendment further guarantees equal protection of the law for all people who reside here — including all children — and it guards against the mean-spirited education discrimination that Pearce advocates. The Supreme Court rejected such attacks against immigrant children more than a quarter century ago in when it upheld their equal right to a public education in Plyler v. Doe.

Pearce hides behind claims of the burden on taxpayers. But denying innocent children a basic education is penny-wise and pound-foolish. The Supreme Court recognized the greater “costs to the Nation” that such laws would impose by “promoting the creation and perpetuation of a subclass of illiterates within our boundaries, surely adding to the problems and costs of unemployment, welfare and crime.”

These proposed laws by Pearce are not just unconstitutional and fiscally irresponsible. They are unjust.

I call on all candidates for public office in Arizona, Democrats and Republicans, to denounce this immoral legislation. To stand silent in the face of unjust laws that target children is to fail. I will stand up for what is right, even if I am standing alone.

— Vince Rabago is a Democratic candidate for Arizona attorney general.


  1. Pay a fine and back taxes to, “get right with the law?” You’re an Idiot Rabago! I can think of no kinder way to phrase it. Political correctness, is destroying this Nation . The only action I will support to allow these people to “get right with the law” is immediate deportation. If they then care to return to the United States LEGALLY, I will support them. Sorry, to have to break it to you pal, but the majority of the people polled, support my position.

  2. Clearly, Arizona needs lawmakers who 1) know the law and 2) don’t try to make new laws that oppose our constitutional rights.

    And we need people like Mr. Rabago who knows the difference.

    Do we really need another unconstitutional law that will cost our financially strapped state more money to defend in courts?

    How about some laws that don’t mean money for Rep. Pearce’s buddies and that actually do something about protecting our safety and making our state fiscally healthy?

  3. Thanks for the report, what is this pearce guy thinking! hes and idiot

  4. I have two questions… 1. Isn’t the basic premise of the ‘American Dream ‘preluded by illegal immigrants who STOLE many of my ancestors (africans and american indians) land/life in order to promote their own agenda?
    2. Who are the ‘people’ polled in Arizona that support this absurb law, which by the way is costing your state money by the billions and isn’t securing the borders the least bit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




Check Also

Farming groups are worried that there may not be enough workers like this one, shown harvesting bell peppers, to bring in the winter vegetables after the government shutdown delayed the processing of visas for farm workers. (Photo courtesy Farmworker Justice)

Arizona-grown produce bill good for families in poverty

The Arizona-Grown Fruit and Vegetable Incentive bill is a win for everyone – for children and families living in poverty, for seniors on fixed incomes and for rural and urban farmers across the state.